- Impact & Earn
- Posts
- What are the arguments for and against increasing the minimum wage?
What are the arguments for and against increasing the minimum wage?
Introduction
In the latter half of the 2010s, South Korea embarked on a bold journey to tackle income inequality and revitalize its economy by significantly raising the minimum wage. This policy shift aimed to uplift low-income workers while stimulating economic growth. However, as with any major policy change, the repercussions on the broader economy needed careful examination. A recent study delved into the long-term effects of these minimum wage increases on key macroeconomic indicators in South Korea. The findings provide valuable insights into the complex relationship between labor policy and economic performance.
The Research Approach
This study employed a sophisticated large-firm search and matching model to analyze the multifaceted impact of the minimum wage hikes. By looking beyond the surface, researchers aimed to uncover the intricate dynamics at play. The results, while shedding light on several aspects, are a reminder that the effects of such policies are far from straightforward.
Effects on Employment
One of the expected outcomes of raising the minimum wage is to enhance the lives of low-income workers. However, the study revealed a paradoxical twist. It found that increasing the minimum wage led to a reduction in employment, particularly among those with lower productivity levels. This phenomenon is a stark reminder of the trade-offs inherent in labor policy decisions.
Productivity Boost
While the reduced employment may seem concerning at first glance, the study also unveiled a silver lining. The average labor productivity of those who remained employed increased. This surge in productivity, in turn, provided firms with the impetus to invest in capital, potentially boosting the long-term growth prospects of the South Korean economy.
Balancing the Scales
The research results suggest that although an increase in the real minimum wage, such as the 15% rise in 2018, may lead to decreased total employment and a slight dip in gross output (approximately 3.5% and 1.0%, respectively), it's essential to recognize the nuances in the broader economic picture. The challenge lies in balancing the immediate benefits for low-wage workers with the potential impacts on the labor market and overall economic performance.
Conclusion
The South Korean experiment with substantially raising the minimum wage in the late 2010s has generated insights that extend beyond national borders. It highlights the intricacies of labor policy decisions and their impact on employment, productivity, and economic growth. While the study's results may underscore the need for a cautious, balanced approach, they also reaffirm the importance of continuously exploring innovative strategies to address income inequality and stimulate economic progress. In the pursuit of a fairer and more prosperous society, South Korea's experience provides valuable lessons for policymakers worldwide.
Reference:
Byoung, Hoon, Seok., Hye, Mi, You. (2022). Macroeconomic impacts of increasing the minimum wage: The case of Korea. Economic Modelling, 113:105880-105880. doi: 10.1016/j.econmod.2022.105880
Reply